Reviews

"Break[s] fresh analytical and methodological ground and respond[s] intelligently to alternative explanatory models pertaining to [its] respective subject. [It is a] significant contribution that will elicit scholarly engagement."

"A sophisticated navigation of the intersections of race, status, and sexuality and the permeability of each boundary."

"This thoroughly researched, extremely well-documented study gives us a clear understanding of how rulers constantly had to negotiate between what would ensure stability in the colony, what morality commanded, and what their perception of races suggested."

"An impressive study of the role played by race and sex in creating the familiar racial hierarchy of early New Orleans. Among Spear’s many contributions is her detailed uncovering of the competing definitions of race as well as arguments about just what relationships between the various races should look like."

"Spear opens a window into New Orleanians' legal affairs regarding race under different regimes with distinct legal traditions."

"A wonderful survey of race relations in colonial Louisiana... Bringing things down to an individual level she manages to fuse the micro and macro, creating a layered portrait of colonial society. Her focus on women, their avenues for freedom, and the different responses to their prescribed social role make this interesting for scholars of the regulation of human sexuality, not just race history."

"A thoughtful, comprehensive, wide-ranging treatment of the subject of race in New Orleans in the colonial and early national period. It is rare to see a book as thoroughly documented as this one, and as rich in colorful and appropriately chosen examples to illustrate larger points of argument."

"A timely, path-breaking, and totally convincing refutation of the prevailing ideologically driven view that all southern whites were always hopeless racists and all women of color were always helpless victims. It helps lay the basis for our new understanding of the diversity of the culture of the USA."

"By focusing on everyday practice as well as on law and policy, Jennifer Spear vividly explains how free people of color became a significant social group in colonial New Orleans. She takes full advantage of tangibly special circumstances—regional economic conditions, governance by multiple regimes, and rich archival records—to replace stale assumptions about the Crescent City’s peculiar society with fresh insights into its comparative importance in early American history."